Rich Curtner
Federal Public Defender
FEDERAL PUBLIC DEFENDER
DISTRICT OF ALASKA
550 W. 7th Avenue, Suite 1600
Anchorage, Alaska 99501
(907) 271-2277
Attorney for Defendant
Ray R. Brown
Dillon & Findley
510 L Street, Suite 603
Anchorage, AK 99501
(907)277-5400
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF ALASKA
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, ) NO. xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
)
Plaintiff, )
)
vs. ) DEFENDANTS xxxxxxxx AND
) xxxxxxxxxxxx JOINT MOTION TO
xxxxxxxxxxxxxx, ) SUPPRESS IN-COURT
xxxxxxxxxxx, ) IDENTIFICATION AND MOTION
xxxxxxxxxx, ) FOR EVIDENTIARY HEARING
)
Defendants. )
____________________________________)
A period of
excludable delay under 18 U.S.C. § 3161(h)(l)(F) may occur as the result of the
filing/granting/denying of this motion.
COME NOW THE DEFENDANTS, xxxxxxxxxxxxx, by and through counsel Rich Curtner, Federal Public Defender, and xxxxxxxx, by and through counsel, xxxxxxxxxx, and moves this court for an order suppressing the in-court identification of xxxxxxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxx by xxxxxxxxxx at trial.
The defendants request the court schedule an evidentiary hearing.
This motion is brought pursuant to Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 12 and the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution, and is supported by the Memorandum of Law, Affidavits, and exhibits attached hereto.
Respectfully submitted,
FEDERAL PUBLIC DEFENDER
DISTRICT OF ALASKA
________________________________
Rich Curtner
Federal Public Defender
Attorney for Defendant xxxxxxxxxx
________________________________
Ray R. Brown
Attorney for Defendant xxxxxxxxxxx
Rich Curtner
Federal Public Defender
FEDERAL PUBLIC DEFENDER
DISTRICT OF ALASKA
550 W. 7th Avenue, Suite 1600
Anchorage, Alaska 99501
(907) 271-2277
Attorney for Defendant
Ray R. Brown
Dillon & Findley
510 L Street, Suite 603
Anchorage, AK 99501
(907)277-5400
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF ALASKA
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, ) NO. xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
)
Plaintiff, ) MEMORANDUM OF POINTS
) AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT
vs. ) OF DEFENDANTS xxxxxxxxxx AND
) xxxxxxxxxx JOINT MOTION TO
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, ) SUPPRESS IN-COURT
xxxxxxxxxxxxxx, ) IDENTIFICATION
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, )
)
Defendants. )
____________________________________)
I. INTRODUCTION.
xxxxxxxxx and xxxxxxxxxx are charged with joining a conspiracy to conceal the assets and property of Robert xxxxxx by fraud and misrepresentation in order to permit xxxxxxx to discharge his debts in bankruptcy proceedings while maintaining control over property of the bankruptcy estate.
Critical to the Government's case is the testimony of xxxxxxx that xxxxxxxxxx made admissions to this conspiracy to Mrs. xxxxxxxxxx on September 2, 1990. These alleged admissions implicate xxxxxxxxxx as well.
Mr. xxxxxx and Ms. xxxxxxx have denied
these allegations during adversary proceedings in the Bankruptcy Court. Mrs. Brockie has
testified in bankruptcy äÝÉðl’x°E¤/6È¥·^ë �ë”®m©ýwŽÑRêuÜ2ú¼ÓÍzµêÀ�›öo²¹e¹ˆ' £ÀR®rÝ(h¹€™†±¦?R/tÀÖ”šóוûÌ6»h›šd©È¦š¸W*I,×vÈÞ}ð¼´N uVûÌÃ9¢c€Œc¹VË�þcCÃÌeÙúa¾ýT
™ÑZæi›söý‘Ô4àZ¦�U'WÀÕ¹¾µ|¢‚eâÀRV²~Éay¸Ó™‡½èc#uÄÉѶ²¨kBÍJX£ÌO9¢cÕ*®€ïе]*×|ÕÒa¾ý¼ÍJEX£ÌÃ9¢cØÍl³¦££mzbCÃÌeÙ¢vð¼tHŒÆCàrË ´©ÓÍd¾VçÎ_*ÄÉ”~²´xµŸt êÛYVµu›hÔˆƒ²ôH oW,˜‚„ð¾µ{‰'
£Ü^&²wÂà®É္Z-À=ÀÏ.¤¯³ Ã;óÕÕæ4ÐÓ ×{ŒÒ }KKÚÚ=òŽWœ˜:J‚ÚC[åzÖ(¶¤šÍN—VÒ‡V&H‰ì…4ýˆk·˜k ¡Šzô;Ã9u¥Ø•–ðç.yěվýµ{Àh[àÛB3®±„i¸Îò‡¶ O*Ûs�Ôhð�¨FN•OûÌ› ´€ ~óVþ–¨;C›Àr�½a¦¸uˆÚCVêuÍ$©©ÉŠl¤ô�*H�‚�+óúZ¸ˆ
b
æÒR©~›#h±Éˆ˜µ¦S"=ÕÓÝ£ý³jƒsê×V5³tÕÍz¼Ó¦ƒ±HR-”|�Óg·µ¶NžrPæÇÏ(¬~€€l³ãœð*HLÓÝ~É×¶¸c
ŒØä~Õ5©ýÓ…b§âÎC;ÙÃÌ=®³`·�bHëÛC½iÚ1e®€‚ˆð;ôF;eÙÃÌð¼´jN tFVûÌO9¢cÃÍk¯ÏëΤe1'Æt×Þ|£ý¶
ˆiDð”Ô'úVÒÃ-¥þ–¨;W Uß”PÒô.¨¥•ÌækÉ.¾¨ÃˆiðÿÎO+HõÞÌ|®úJµ�fîÑYútÝL�Õ�‚¹¦;Z%iØ•ˆÿ®ªo Ó;G½¹=LÐ'ËÓ1®Ðç€ð%#1w‰?ÇÔ`¤ð¼ „kNL£÷üaŽr͈~ý^Ñßùc%
\ÎØ|Óø0„µbH‰ÑYê}Ò"»©É‚cðô�X&ÓÞ”j¼©.£‚
bíÚR¿hÈ ´Ì”Σá^0t×Þ”±³¾.
‚iàÝA$úoÔÍd¯Òãž±
W&”pÈÈz±¶¿N„cR÷ÝÝ(¹zÔ„b³Vçšð7Z×¹Õ²o¤ýnÍÕSêhÈ(µ³€šb¥âÎX,ÕÒÀh©¿.±ÍqïÕCµu›.kýĘ‹ðôX&n�ÔÒð±»yNŒtHöÕE ´oÞˆiýÂÿΤe1Ý{ÕÓ.‘°¿
€bY£ÛÝa®sÅÍX³ò‹´c$ZÏÑn�™a¾®s˜À^í5‡n©Áƒ3ìYöÐ6Izb�ËŠ!®ªo¾ÍT<7Ïñ
T¼tÕ5 »Á€‡¼¼HxWIÈÖÑ£ýòY_Ä':äÁ[ ¨9…¤Dó€º� e1àDíþ3ò©¿ÀcRìÆÚ5³tÎ×-¨â‹¢/^™ŠNõ›Z•�B&:ÍûqVÅZø‰á�ž}±¸ÀlÀÕŠ!òª0Ýç
bRóŠªzÕa^‰ù¡«íTàU7Z{ÀÖݼ¤à.-ª'<îÑDaòLŠÄ-�Å᛼JÜx�Ò`¦¸©ŠfCìÚ›.¼;íŸ#ýþ–¨;HZÕЫ—}þý•ÌO£rÕa®µÉž-³õ‹4�ÒÚt©³o¤ˆcHú”VúzÝ'd¹Á›‡¤VéqÄÕ”’¯µm„bDVðÃX3´;Ï‚-´Î‹ä”
V!Ño�Š7ééöH…fCVðÀÚ5¿€™e¼¦±1ÃÌeÙ¢v¨ýf„ÀCç;Ï.ú�Òž#ð4ô�X(
�ÏÜ|©ú}¸ˆ' ç”`£uÞL¥Ø•–¨¦ Z'W;ÐÎÛ¤æ²g
‰bV÷ÃR/®b›€d±Ìï�¾VW/ÕoÒ›h¿¯ú*�'OûÌÃ9úrÎÍlýçžµ1WIÚÝq�©að±h ÍÚX{‰tÕ$ú¾Ï˜a´Và‡U'WÕ•’l¨µzëÍ;
½çRæ4Þ,3ýወ¹çR7WrÇ›üµ±¿`N¯uèÝRmúzÏ™l¾ÈãŠðH~;ÜtÃÒzðœôTAžwV½ˆ”1äªàá¸Ò£3èàDíŸ3ò»hÀÒVêwÂ{úžçÍY¹ã�k Yˆ›æxº¯b±Ÿ%V:ëÕCV»}Ý(i¼Ö„šðòZ xÅ›À¸¸ú~Ÿw÷ÑSLÐsÚƒiªÒHU,Àx�Ôhð�¨@ÍEEàßÒ$ö;Á�a¸ãм:WIÒÀiÄ´.¤µbH „Ó_£tÝa‰¸Ð™h½ãœq[H�‚�-ñúz¸ŒsedîÕ\©;É$k¸Òˆ€³¦Tc=‡ÊÁ¿©áL@ÍûÌO9úvΞd¾Áêε F2ÁrÕ€.츷V=ˆbYæÙ…aŸcÈ„o´¦¬þc:H•¹ã¨a³¶n
N…ÕDVæcË-»´Îˆiðî‡Hc
ÇÞÆx³¹kð„iHæÆ¿hÏ(`²Î”βàI&WiÉÞ”’¼´e˜wú”t.¯iÏÍl®Œˆ¿L0Ž!ŽÈ~±³äTA�9:|޾‡1ä'Ó�l³VÕº‰2UÝÛsÕ÷h±°n×”t1£OÒ,¿®€ÅZá_¦¼^$ÀÉ–#Œú&’”'%”d¿s×$$ý舂µªHZ7WiÉÞ”²²®z€
bå”r9²rÙ„yý‘¦‡£VHU,Àx�›G¤ý© ž+7÷”Ô4¨;È‚x®¦�¶7ùš=Ù¢v¨¥N€ÁDàz×a¿«Åƒd¾ªÎZ-HÕÓÑsÐÐg¤Ío £ÍX¨;Ò/d©ÉŒ‚£X¦,Tcrԛǵ¸úzŒsWJ¬ÇG ´%‡Â}ãŒãÚJV0Ä|Ï›]„„–-SÏaX÷™Ý ·rÌ”7ý5Á΄*
H›œJ�ó.‚¸`ŒÆHÂ;î)÷µÕ…#ìYõžZ-ITŽËŠ××ì�9TóÕYV‰Oâ
Hà‚‹�¾«Z.qØ�”“šúZ€bV«ãhúIÞŠx±ÁôÌî'W?S"À=ÅÔk£ý® ™'EåÑÉa®tŸÑ"®ç€îX¶¾«æ~îátƒ”d"ÚWþ|ø»ÏƒyýçƒR/R�øó=‰³cµž'@9²�$¿|Î-l¯‚Ó¯ð!ãWoWT�ÖÕ´¸úoNƒh£ÛQa®sÞÍy´ÍãιzbS"ÄmÄÕk´ý»
ÍnCVëÕË1¿uʼn-´¦�¥1W TÎÇx�úL¹±kH•ÌOûc›(©ýÁÍk¢ã€_c�ÔÁo®ô.‡ˆ' ç”P´~›5bý�ÀãÚó7=ÅÒÚ¾¸¨.ƒcHëÑYa»;Ø�x¿€«ÃðOHcÀuÈÈ.½¨©
ŒkõÑÕ(´|ŽÍYµÿÉ¢&W ØØhÃúm±±k
ÍÀ_Žö(¶±É‚c±ô‹HoW Ïß”iµ¿wðšb£ÕG¿zÉ(cº€Œšðî
pÌÒÀð•µz�)H4êØ[a¢cÕu¥Øþ–ðHZcÒoÈÞ`´ýµcçhBð”Ú/¾;ÈŒiýõ…µ'WH›Àr�½aüýf
ÍÃRVêu›5¯¯ÎÍl£ãŠ;ÙÃÌ=¼´jð•ûšY©kÚ/3á��ÐÝ|‹b3I!ÒËÕ¾ý‰Z7¡BUTåÛY5÷}Ú€d±Ù¼Î“1W