Mary C. Geddes

Assistant Federal Defender

FEDERAL PUBLIC DEFENDER

FOR THE DISTRICT OF ALASKA

550 W. Seventh Avenue, Suite 1600

Anchorage, Alaska 99501

(907) 271-2277

Attorney for Defendant




UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT



FOR THE DISTRICT OF ALASKA





UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, ) NO. xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

)

Plaintiff, )

)

vs. ) DEFENDANT'S BRIEF

) IN SUPPORT OF MOTION

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, ) TO SET SENTENCING IN KODIAK

)

Defendant. )

____________________________________)



EXCLUDABLE DELAY:

A period of excludable delay under 18 U.S.C. 3161(h) may

occur as the result of the filing/granting/denying of this motion.



COMES NOW THE DEFENDANT, xxxxxxxxxxxxxx, by and through counsel Mary C. Geddes, Assistant Federal Defender, and submits this memorandum in support of his earlier motion to set the sentencing hearing in his case in Kodiak.

At a hearing before this honorable court last Friday, October 30, 1998, the court sought additional information and authority from the movant.

I. Is the court prohibited by the language of 28 USC 81A from holding any sessions of court in locations other than those specified by Congress?

On June 6, 1900, Congress established a district court for the District of Alaska, dividing the territory into three recording divisions. 31 Stat. 321. The act provided that a regular term of court be fixed for each division. It also provided that special terms be held "at such place or places as may be deemed necessary and expedient." United States v. Stockslager, 116 F. 590, 593 (9th Cir. 1902) citing, 31 Stat. 321. After the admission of Alaska to the Union, Congress enacted Section 81A of Title 28 of the United States Code. This act created a single judicial district in Alaska, and although the act did not divide the district into divisions, it did identified five locations where "[c]ourt shall be held" within the state: Anchorage, Fairbanks, Nome, Ketchikan and Juneau.

The question before the court is whether the mandatory language, "[c]ourt shall be held," found in Section 81A precludes the court from designating other locations within the district for court sessions.

In interrupting the meaning of the phrase "shall be held," Section 81A must be read so as to harmonize with other sections of Title 28, Chapter Five. Cf. Robinson v. Shell Oil Co., --- U.S. ---, 117 S.Ct. 843, 849, 136 L.Ed. 2d 808 (1997) (The plainness or ambiguity of statutory language is determined by reference to the language itself, the specific context in witch that language is used, and the broader context of the statute as a whole); Colautti v. Franklin, 439 U.S. 379, 392, 99 S.Ct. 675,684, 58 L.Ed. 2d 596 (1979) (The elementary canon of construction that a statue should be interpreted so as not to render one part inoperative). Section139 allows the district court, by rule and order, to determine the times for regularly transacting judicial business "at the places fixed by this chapter." The section directs that in only one of the locations "fixed by this chapter" is a district court required to be in session on all business days. At other locations, "a session of the court shall continue until terminated by order." It is this section that allows the district court in Alaska to maintain part-time schedules in Nome, Ketchikan, and Juneau. This section must be read to prohibit 'regularly-scheduled' court business in any other locations other than those specified by Congress.

Section 141 authorizes the district courts to hold "special sessions" in other locations on an 'as-needed' basis. Section 141 states:

Special sessions of the district court may be held at such places in the district as the nature of the business may require and upon such notice as the court orders.

This enactment was clearly intended to grant broad discretion to the district court in its determinations as to whether a court session should be held outside of the statutorily-identified court locations. A 1963 amendment to this section clarified the authority of the district court to make this determination. The amendment deleted language which previously required deference to the "rules approved by the judicial council for the circuit." P.L. 88-139. Thus, by applying the canon of statutory construction, 2A Sutherland Statutory Construction; 47.06, in reading 81A in conjunction with 139 and 141, it is clear that Congress' intent in listing locations in which "court shall be held" does not preclude the district court from designating other location within the district for special sessions. See United States v. Hill, 42 F. 2d 812 (4th Cir. 1930) (Holding of special term by district court at a place not provided in act was authorized under code authorizing special term where nature of business requires); United States v. Kessel, 63 F. 433 (N.D. Iowa 1894) (a8k_g,?SO[=X5 Ejk3Ȩ& ̝: ,M RQ>'%ͨ]:؝1F=AjG(7ךrtկ|_^+Rk=@<! 3AE#之b}ֽ<Eh/@O!n$&H?I[=Y| I&Euѿ<`ȴ 7й(I Y8V?:#:3L|]^&8;ʣ=]Թ ˌI(Ae$5!MGɃ^,L]+4ʙ]-C/B*7Ɲ\!5E2AR_j/<4ZܦtʀY/@RY&?=˾ =[ܤtO|I&E(׹>ʔH&[ Ϥ/DOT[>C.ˬ' =tY5]TB>.=ר& tO|[^j.rҤM7Ɠɣ;^3\ &T?տ1M;][rȥ(LOK)B?̣!\";X|^V#k:Ĺ;@[ǝ< 5KC%>&̮LrܝtE?J$%ש Fr[ ξ5DRF)8$]ry<ܝC/K^C+8!Ы;L̿; `ORc?*M7tN9G/ %XH&Utҧ=FN]+ k|ԓ dCSmnmsk!լ_}*7є18A^$%7ס@<՗ӭhZ=S9VkȈoL*;ܾ5OJ8^.&$X('|J R$;=rD3Gͫ: nF)dkd z0&eOK)B?ë Mr5հ ?\U/"R<˨!H!6(^Kj&&]:&E) V9-:&[ӹzX5@OY#%XƬZ7 ߯1B9JO+;̬r֒Z!['կ8O RW+S8̮r\ S'DQԶz6> >f7Ƣ3FAӮ1ˉC2< 9unֽH<Ƥ*7ф18A+^%У7כ@<=3ҤQԓO"K9Edģ~`[҇S!|OZdec{AӭtрF8ZO?C/%Ѭ]7ɫ8E?K jYƥ!j= Ro, <&bwC3=];S:X0KMLV!eXƄL!=םI5Ej'%ľ>HhʕK2z6> >f7Ƣ[3AӮ1C2'+E8˞]7 sKL|ek eB[hZb@GjԵec{\٣:^.BbxB-k7ƤZ;Ҧ0E)>A9о"ɖJ7 ==_ X/8Ѥ5ƃA7 t'V_R/?3=]Sޥ:ݐI(N#k=п]:U'DbN^QG:w♾3zNY2ӾqG "7E3 U!Z8$1r [ȸ Y|KbxT#&C.̠rMr t'VMR/%r̾3ƚH۝2_8GS9?=^:Sɥt ;J .Uk3֞Jr~q;ߝ)@M+2tF&@5םykRPR>( Ĺ= Ϧ=׀bG>8$#{K2L^{eн|dʴGLtcseԸ&ݬ}1C/A S9?=!ƞGSگtɄX(O:*"ͤE=ի _/M jD$!_7 ߳| B$Y8Ѣ0G5['^|C)$&ͨ3HS ϯt͍O|Z Dj; ѤL!ƚ [ܰ;D0 O.Q'7֒G&tկ|NOOj_kǡ1ƞG&t (G8/;ˤ&]ҬtӐY(KON(.<â[1ξ&M(@ .>!ՖG_*79 A+^%У7@<?' *[$; l/S:X/@ ^j< 4ƖG [Ͼ=׀D(ӟ\D%97׾ =ޥ! +MjG(̮>Ɏ 1 :ɢ9I[#P$ɢ3F<[~'I5D%k=ƬrE[=ׁC?KRY3*rM7ɥt\9R@O+C$ѢX\= ظ|IAjXk֨?H5t (OTB>">rJ͝%̊^g^$9nֽH<Ƥ*7ф18A+^%У7כ@<5κ3OS]^$:nɄY3\j'VSVjĈo( Ĺ= Ϧ=׀bG:F"עJ7ɥtE(\O:V.̹;]: ԩ(O,C.ľrZr0H9#e_./4ʿ&H[ί#рX9WOR+%=H6ܾ= :ZAjD*ѯ pV0ޥ.C$R'}tNr,Zjs3˩nHv(ZBT8$hG6񛃟:O8RZ>D=䩊=˞S; 5׃|O4.geaG&݁/O1Ejz{!GS(iO$J E>q'˩L Yظ N9K vD*f LJSBgeyA1sk셁 `BxY,<&{w3=]:݀X0KMLRmѯ/<̨MnɄdr!^zkrrקJWto \jk{! ~fZ /*;ʣrM ӯvLr] v%eٯ7K(@UjY.̣pG;~qܾ9\ARG9Ydģ~j[҇S0n[Avu6' 0懝m|AOS89&ͨ$X;^.BO?S9ʿ7{'BBtܹ|^BjR>%GrS=X5%";֤<S/̝'ʌM2@RQ)8&E=ʝ=C2R #C"rD3[#ɢ5^$2[8=@<[S<ܝF3BOD8k'! ǝoaKS)?= 'jC(#eV.@!ڻ:i )\jknYl\!Ƀ OCc83e6Fز O?OYj.>̣Lpؔ$|N^$dי7݃6 ҤfD B$/̨nɄY3~` OKjc_[z|[D{brZ"OT䇰YZbN^$dי=˃4n|G |-[97r'S|_Rj?r=}ޥ!ˑ /BR^jk>ĮLr #B5Z/S8̮rҞ]:[&ګ.^RFjX=̨1#=tL9OV..%̹7LUȥ c2AV>#rJ;Ҽ1C2|&:y$\7ϴ=ӹ|D K+T%3F<[S'D|w#7/行/1ʿ&GI[ٯ&ՌD9L 9uX\= عsE2@/Tmʹr˘]r-ɢ9[/R/|X'Srר3 կtڊD*G R%#rO7ӮYԑB9RG$D.̣4̏@<tѫ?E R\+:nH<[*^9 X+%rУ7@=̀NQZD<.;!MWt n]ffnւYl\!ɃOCc8eF O?OYj.>̣pؔL$؋|^dיi7ݹ6ҤnD8B$/̨nY3~q` OKjc~[SzNrJOFb~|"$y(iO$J E>q'˩L YدhZ=S9VkȈoL*;ܾ5OJ8^.&$X('|\S0;>&A3ͦ5 3Z#[<ͤrџL_&޾|^R[jR*鸅rG$7ܝE: R.k<;LڔtZ=$<&{w3J=:X0KMtB$|G;S( ɯ/Yjkag0& mFRT$?=3[ ί0B98(&̢Gr[ٯ& ?C jVkģ4[7Av^Ԧ9LF8Q$ѥrL< =K,8rârLS˯:ЀD?A R_G$7Ƹ];H[ͫ:~>M>OfƢ3ўF<ܴ1ѣ2,9Vuֽ6; M.ɯ0^=]O89nY3ɅSOz_,]yy͇SJm|E@/C8ʣ7L<t؝L=AR^/"&ɨ%Nկ:^4#eY#*;ʣZrؤ=I9R[>Qkѿ<֑L [ ԫ0 &:YAȈoăL*;^5OS8.l&_][Ӥ1ʊ^=GP+<ЫH19D%N]+ FrԠSWtqOJdCkeeLSe]~rf& ا1E)#eY#.rˤG7Ƒ$^5@jX*ʹ=O=S&ӹ: ^%R/¾4Dr~0^.ZO"k: LS ڝ;ԈC(JO$.rZ&[Ϲ!^|=?Ry=#&50ϫ0_,t"ˬrF1zB9 C8*rǨ'O5ׄF%@R_G9'Ⱦ]3[ξ=C2Z/X/&ўG5 1ԫ0OAdc.Į= 3 1L3APv*ll$yG䗁$؋ b*OQ$*;ɴr'_0 Q{$Ѥ̦>][̝:C/KTND+dl$XڇOfOH$*ɴr [ڿ0QF%V"rJ'tN|MDv*ll$yG䗁$؋ b*OQ$*;ɴr'_0 Q"н;ʙ =tج9K](D%}H,YfȤ+j['O;OPj۳*;ʣ=JئoY,S] @֙;nֽH<Ƥ*7ф;:G3 ̠!L5YjKK+T8Ǥ; =7ܝE:Zw!լlYMv$Y,<&{w%ìD;S8ә9 [+rᢍ9 1=ӹrYe A֙nH<[*L3 ^3 ̠!ƥLjZ=};+rh?6F Ȥ0F5 QV?ֽ<$XգS.z=[Ad~kա; &O$ b*OC2.=׬;Sظ8ЋO~B 9uXģH>[֝< ?KCj_kɡ%̙Nr&ʝ4F RK)Y"רhZ"~Y_0$OR[t*r ݐ5ԌF%m(R^/.'ɬ[pغ][Ų, 3K9$ЮrјF91ҤQ ORA#\wլlE;ESh`ORc-<3E AЈO/KVhe*ݵQ*Sݝ=C1J+R-̡rɞ_7랉S[tC:YwX>5םykRPX>&>}ڝ1ސF="23*Zr5I. 3Q8˪X rtȾ| $G!9@< \9ZRY",r ][ۓ,R$VH=j&>ʴD7S7Y5#"ˮ3A3$/DQNBt=k!Gr(?iE2H[pk;ȨrN۟؈C0C R9&>ʴL ϣ1Y|[.=kա]= 1՝3D \-$ѹRkר=#rƴ ɣ3^M?Ck47ƟL &܈K5JOC#ѯkrG1{K2L#:kɤnևH<*73 G3 ̠!ƥL5jK(MC,'&̨rLSԦ5ۉO|#eR*rĹ < ίzY,Se^F;Z" / ~D_O#Nk؛? &k|J [8 ĹrM'Б_=JO:j6̬B~Ɩ[0O2@jX'Ƣ!]r ;د8O K>Vkֽ¤&]7[1sOL#ѯknɤnH[L3 ^3"7g7ןO8R^$T%׾&̘G! 1?D#:k"[![tO.Y/8'Ѩr ؤ7ЋM|G Z3=>Ө &ݝ; |R !ƀ@ί'E|]N%ѯkrA=عz/@Qv[uօ>!S(aEH'[q;Zr)5˟C$,=<Ƙ\Vϐ!ʑE8$OR//4 &ʝ2 |ROO.N8Ƚ=ܚL:͐L=BHtjõ.r'[QEڝ;B9AXj- &[Ԯt'VRO-A9rĐL<WtԾ4 =R#7ƟL3 =ʝB9v)*7rM< | R981ʠY3$R5Z &?&Z;89F KjX'տ0E+[1հ ||.p3?H[Ш1E:[ R+/4Z7ƀί'E)+R?ѿ$ &S[t?XvD*;#r[hK2z6> ,f3Ȥ+j4[Я'O;OPc/.7ˮLr7ɳtX/BjVk7 rƴ !ϯ8XOK$Z.ר'L6[6ܝX9M Q8k'4˔\0܃O2@^@%8X rΦ-O9L%Rk:A3 1ٳ|X %D'ר=rGY |z6> >f7Ƣ3FAӮ1ˉC2:krѨ[?ƘSۣ:O2Gj["Ѩ+[6v^| %Ee3}~tF5]ΐv4ʣD퓝C1=B+6̬Brɣ"S|M 9^'ѢX r&گgXB(.̾'L [ ,f3Ȥ+j4[Я'O;OP >,nֽH<'" ^qM8C$慸6E;M8 e!N]+ dע5! M{Ƀ'VLD+4]^Ԧ-iG/*pH9S7Y5\>Xk&ă\&~q$Ҽ5EH?S">jW$X|X ^T?/%̹rLSѣ7ؑC3A R_j*_} Q0E.G$%ס<G{ͫ2^ %C.Į!Ƅ\ = ( R+ѯ#<3 ۫7^4%k3K S޸1E2R@O+Z%Ѩ;ː &-ɥqSbx^8C$ʫ& 1tC/A9,6rZɯt -ZTR#8!֤F<ԤYԮE8EO,E?󹅽 ՘Z7['Ӿ9Cz.3ݵ*! M{Ƀ'VLD+4]^Ԧ-iG/*phʝ 8,}'b}EhQ S:YυpG&V8 zD' 7LѦ-_>Ze%n_O κ5y+kRhX?Ġ> 1ʝ9Fr  >=/@QNGGѯwl3z'"2֋^qC "7{7 bRg<~bڻ:, bx^vEᇏc$XGShbxUji_K[bӟ `wzl0#Fv `]b@=;ֽ<} єQ;:C  c&5H Y, uq0-hȃ v,$κ5s#e t*rpʋ͐5F%Hm(j^.'ɖ[ptN :Yw_YlGts C,'hrDح!ՄX~]C$.7׬Er{K2Lt=A yoBYj>}?Olx AkJ~h - G9 Mv߸t~ML=(ppOixnP#evEᇏc$XS,bxLjgiَ_K [Nb `wzl0~#Fv `8"Fnǿ ʋ1)^X|%Mu֙rpƛQEY.zRP|h:woĵ{`Yy6˝} l=C @k~q Q 8v l v~L$S(p#n$+im'eN\ Xڕ[r,ĔQQLRghՎi_ ƠyNYj>y?OuxA0~!Jh " -Fǿ Mv^߸|M0t=)ppEO&za|]P:voc$yG۝hbxUǰi_[b 8`vl0#Fv~ Sn +1f'V\O% uXrQ9ƛYH.~RPehѯw yoĵAY6} Ol={ AkԶ~qh - G 9 lvt~ML=(pp#Oixm#eNE `$XڕS,ĄQxLjgiَ_"ؙ~qhɃ/DO!w$?Ph[S=Y|IEjĈo